by myuser.ai
Get it free on Shopify or Wix
Pop-up strategy

Pop-up Mistakes: A 10-Minute Test on Phone and Desktop

A 10-minute test, phone first, for pop-up mistakes that push shoppers away: early timing, a small close button, extra fields, fake urgency, failed codes.

A cluttered Before pop-up shouting WAIT!!! DON'T GO!!! with four fields and a countdown, an arrow, and a calm After pop-up offering 10% off your first order with one email field.
On this page
  1. Before you start (1 minute)
  2. On your phone (6 minutes)
  3. On your computer (3 minutes)
  4. What to fix first
  5. Frequently asked questions
  6. Try it on your store
  7. Sources

The pop-up mistakes that push shoppers away are a box that covers the product too soon, a close button that's hard to hit, too many fields, fake urgency, a pop-up that keeps coming back and a code that fails at checkout. They rarely show up in the editor. They show up on a real phone, on the live site, in the first few seconds, so ten minutes with your phone and a computer finds them before shoppers do. Run this test after every change to the pop-up or to the coupon behind it.

Key takeaways

  • Test the live site in a private window, on your phone first and then on a computer, after every change.
  • If the pop-up covers the product before you've seen it, move it to a later trigger.
  • If your thumb misses the close button once, make it bigger: WCAG 2.2 asks for at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels at level AA, and 44 by 44 at the stricter AAA level.
  • Reload the page mid-test: a countdown that starts over is fake, so take it out.
  • Finish by applying the prize code at checkout, once with a cart over any minimum and once under it.

Before you start (1 minute)

  • Publish, and test the live site. On Wix, pop-ups set to open automatically don't appear in Preview.
  • Open a private window on your phone and on your computer. Many pop-up tools remember a close or a sign-up, so a normal window may show you nothing.
  • Pick two products: one that puts the cart over any minimum order on your prize coupons, and one that leaves it under.
  • Have an email address you can check, and know which trigger your pop-up uses.

If nothing appears at all, stop here and work through why a Wix popup or lightbox isn't showing, or on Shopify, why a Shopify pop-up isn't showing.

On your phone (6 minutes)

  1. Land on a product page and count. You should see the product before anything covers it. If the pop-up arrives at once, move it to a delay of a few seconds, a scroll or a second page; pop-up timing for each kind of page has the defaults.
  2. Look at what's left of the page. You should still be able to tell where you are. If the pop-up fills the screen, cut words until nobody has to scroll inside it, and let a tap on the dimmed page close it. Google's guidance on intrusive interstitials says not to cover the whole page with a dialog, and suggests banners that use a small part of the screen instead.
  3. Close it one-handed, with your thumb. If you miss the X even once, or it sits under the browser's address bar, it's too small or in the wrong place.
  4. Tap the email field. The page should stay still, with the button visible above the keyboard. If the page zooms in on an iPhone, the field text is under 16 pixels, which makes Safari zoom on every tap. If the keyboard hides the button, move the button right under the field.
  5. Count the fields. Email, plus an optional phone number for texts, is plenty. Ask for a birthday later by email, with a small birthday reward as the reason, and collect the address at checkout, where it's needed anyway.
  6. Reload the page and read the copy again. A countdown that starts over, or "only 2 left" on something that never runs out, tells shoppers the rest of the page may be invented too. Keep only real deadlines, stated plainly: "Code ends Sunday at midnight."
  7. Close it, then browse two more pages. It should stay closed, or wait as a small tab the shopper can tap. If it returns on every page, that's a "no" ignored twice. A Wix built-in pop-up set to open automatically shows each time one of its pages loads, so give it fewer pages or open it from a button.
  8. Sign up, then use the code. Copy the code, add the product that clears your minimum and apply the code at checkout. Then empty the cart, add the cheaper product, try again and read the message shoppers would see. A code that fails is the worst thing on this list, because the shopper has already done all the work.

On your computer (3 minutes)

  1. Press Escape. The pop-up should close.
  2. Press Tab a few times. Focus should move through the pop-up's field, button and close control, with a visible outline on each, rather than wandering off into the page behind it.
  3. Check the close button's name. A screen reader should announce something like "Close," not just "button." If you don't use a screen reader, ask whoever built the pop-up to confirm the button has a text label.
  4. Trigger the pop-up the way a shopper would. For exit intent, browse for a few seconds, then move the cursor up past the browser tabs; testing an exit pop-up like a leaving shopper has the full routine.
  5. Look at the pop-up next to the page behind it. Same fonts, same colors, same voice? A pop-up in stock template colors can look like an ad from somewhere else, and shoppers hesitate to type an email into something that doesn't seem to belong to your shop.
  6. Find your test sign-up. In your Wix dashboard, open Contacts and look up the address. The Email column shows its subscription status, which should read Subscribed for a pop-up that asked for email permission. On Shopify, open Spin Wheel's Submissions page to find a Spin Wheel sign-up.
Three AI-drafted wheel pop-ups in different brand colors and fonts, the middle one previewed on the store's site as AI draft 2 of 6 with a Pick button
Spin Wheel drafts its pop-ups from your store's colors, fonts and products, so they start out looking like your shop.
Spin Wheel for Shopify & Wix

Pop-ups that show up at the right moment

Delay, scroll, page-count and exit-intent triggers on desktop and phone, and one pop-up per page load, so they never stack.

What to fix first

Fix in this order, because each problem costs more than the one after it:

  1. Anything that breaks the code at checkout. Check the coupon's end date and minimum order first. A limit on the total number of uses also stops the code for everyone once it's reached, so leave that open on a prize coupon. Creating a coupon code in Wix Stores shows where each setting lives.
  2. Anything that traps a thumb: a close button that's hard to hit, a pop-up that needs scrolling, a field that zooms the page.
  3. Timing and repeat showings.
  4. Copy and design.

Frequently asked questions

Why are pop-ups so annoying?

Usually because of timing and control, not the pop-up itself. Visitors get annoyed when a box covers the page before they've seen anything, when the close button is hard to find, when the form asks for too much, or when it returns after they said no. A pop-up that waits for interest and closes easily feels like an offer, not an obstacle.

Do pop-ups hurt SEO?

They can if they get in the way. Google's page on avoiding intrusive interstitials and dialogs says not to cover the whole page with a dialog, and suggests banners that take up a small part of the screen instead. A pop-up that waits for a sign of interest, covers part of a phone screen and closes easily is a safer choice for shoppers and for search.

How big should a pop-up close button be?

At least 24 by 24 CSS pixels, and 44 by 44 for a control as important as a close button. Those are WCAG 2.2's target sizes: success criterion 2.5.8 (level AA) asks for at least 24 by 24, and 2.5.5 (level AAA) asks for 44 by 44. The X itself can look smaller, as long as the tappable area around it reaches that size and doesn't overlap other buttons.

Try it on your store

Spin Wheel starts you with spin-to-win pop-ups designed from your store's brand, with your own coupons as the prizes, so the checkout step of this test has real codes to try.

Spin Wheel Free forever on Shopify and Wix

Sources

Written by the myuser.ai team

We build marketing apps for online stores: myuser.ai writes and sends emails and texts from a store's own products, and we make Spin Wheel and Session Recordings, free apps for online stores. Product details in our guides are checked against the apps themselves.

Give your next visitor a reason to sign up

Add Spin Wheel, pick a design AI made from your store, and start collecting sign-ups with prizes that work at checkout.

Add to Shopify Add to Wix Free forever · Shopify and Wix · No code