by myuser.ai
Get it free on Shopify or Wix
Pop-up strategy

Email Pop-up Best Practices, With Copy Examples

When an email pop-up should open, what it should ask for and offer, the Wix setting behind each choice, and copy for four kinds of stores to adapt.

A coffee shop pop-up reading Get 15% off your first bag with an email field and a Get my 15% off button, beside a pop-up checklist ticking one field, clear reward, easy to close and phone-friendly.
On this page
  1. When should an email pop-up appear?
  2. How often should a pop-up show?
  3. What should an email pop-up ask for?
  4. What should an email pop-up offer?
  5. What should an email pop-up say?
  6. What should an email sign-up disclaimer say?
  7. Lay it out for thumbs
  8. Test one change at a time
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Try it on your store
  11. Sources

Open your email pop-up a few seconds into a product page or after a scroll on a blog post, ask for an email alone, and put the offer in the headline and again on the button. Stop showing it once someone signs up, keep it away for the rest of the visit once they close it, and test one change at a time.

An email pop-up asks a stranger for something before they've bought anything, so whether it feels like a fair trade comes down to four decisions: when it opens, what it asks for, what it offers and what it says. Each has a sensible default, and most map to a specific setting on Wix.

Key takeaways

  • Open the pop-up a few seconds into a product page and after a scroll on blog posts; Wix's built-in pop-ups offer only a delay, so scroll and page-count timing need an app.
  • Ask for an email alone unless your first email uses a name, and ask for texts with a separate, unticked box.
  • Put the offer in the headline and name it again on the button, as in 'Get $5 off your first tea order' and 'Send my $5 code'.
  • Judge each change by sign-ups per visitor who saw the pop-up, over at least a full week.

When should an email pop-up appear?

Once the visitor has seen what you sell: about 5 seconds into a product page, or after a scroll partway down a blog post, and never again after they sign up. Wix's built-in Popups offer only a delay, so scroll, page-count and exit-intent timing need an app.

The pop-up timing guide has the moment for each kind of page, with the Wix and Spin Wheel setting behind each, how long a delay should be and how timing changes on phones.

A trigger menu with four choices, after 5 seconds, when they scroll, after a few pages or as they're about to leave, next to an exit pop-up on a store page
Four moments to choose from: a few seconds in, a scroll, a few pages or the way out.

How often should a pop-up show?

Never again after a sign-up, and not again in the same visit after a close. Three rules cover it:

  • After a sign-up, stop. A new subscriber who sees the same offer again may wonder whether their code worked. Spin Wheel does this by default for anyone who has signed up in that browser.
  • After a close, give it a rest. At the least, don't show it again in the same visit; a "no" repeated on every page turns into nagging. A small tab at the edge of the screen, called a teaser, lets a shopper reopen it when they're ready. In Spin Wheel, each pop-up's Only once per session setting is on by default.
  • Skip people who came from your emails, if your pop-up tool can recognize them, for example by the tags on your email links.

Wix's built-in pop-ups have no setting for this. In the Wix Editor, one set to open automatically shows each time one of its pages loads. If yours shows on every page, or not at all, these fixes for a Wix popup or lightbox that isn't showing cover both.

What should an email pop-up ask for?

Just an email address, unless your first email will use a name or you also plan to send texts. Each field is one more thing to type, and on a phone, one more trip to the keyboard.

  • Email only. The default. Use it whenever your welcome email doesn't need anything else.
  • Email and first name. Add the name only if your first email will use it, and label the field optional.
  • Email and phone. Two separate permissions. Texts need their own consent, given with a separate, unticked box, as the guide to collecting SMS sign-ups with consent explains.

On Wix, a Subscribe form from Add Elements, then Contact & Forms, adds each person to your contacts with a Subscriber label. In Spin Wheel, the phone number is optional and comes with its own tick box for texts; see how its SMS pop-up asks for consent.

What should an email pop-up offer?

A discount, free shipping, early access, a free sample or a game where every play wins, chosen by what it costs you. Pick it before you write a word, because the headline is the offer.

  • A discount gives the clearest reason to sign up, but it costs you on every order that uses it, including orders that would have happened anyway. Run your numbers through a discount break-even calculator first.
  • Free shipping costs you only on orders that use it. If you already ship free over a set amount, offer it on smaller orders, as the guide to free shipping over a set amount in Wix shows.
  • Early access or a free sample suits stores with thin margins or frequent new products.
  • A game, such as a spin wheel, works best when every play wins something real. These spin wheel prize ideas price a whole prize mix.

Whatever the offer, give the coupon behind it an end date and tick Limit to one use per customer in Wix's coupon settings, so a code that travels stops on a date you choose and can't be reused by the same shopper. Then state those limits next to the offer: the free coupon terms generator writes that fine print from the same settings.

Spin Wheel for Shopify & Wix

Pop-ups that show up at the right moment

Delay, scroll, page-count and exit-intent triggers on desktop and phone, and one pop-up per page load, so they never stack.

What should an email pop-up say?

Four things: a headline that states the offer, one line that says what you'll send and how often, a button that names what they get, and a polite way out. Each example below has those four parts. Swap in your own numbers and promises, and keep only what's true.

Loose-leaf tea: $5 off the first order

  • Headline: "Get $5 off your first tea order"
  • Line: "New blends and brewing tips, about twice a month"
  • Button: "Send my $5 code"
  • Decline: "No thanks"

The line answers the question every shopper has before typing an address: what will you send me, and how often?

Handmade candles: free shipping

  • Headline: "Free shipping on your first order"
  • Line: "New scents first, and never more than one email a week"
  • Button: "Get free shipping"
  • Decline: "Maybe later"

"Never more than one email a week" is a promise, so only write it if your sending schedule keeps it.

Pet treats: a free sample

  • Headline: "A free treat sample with your first order"
  • Line: "New flavors and the odd training tip, twice a month"
  • Button: "Claim my free sample"
  • Decline: "No thanks"

A sample costs you one small item instead of a slice of every order. On Wix, a $ Discount coupon limited to the sample product, for at least its price, makes it free once it's in the cart, though shipping still applies. Choose Apply once per order, so a cart with three samples gets one free, and name the sample product in the success message so shoppers know what to add. Creating a coupon code in Wix Stores shows where each setting lives.

Kids' clothing: early access, no discount

  • Headline: "First look at every new collection"
  • Line: "Subscribers can shop new drops a day before everyone else. About two emails a month."
  • Button: "Get early access"
  • Decline: "No thanks"

This one costs no margin at all, but it only works if you really do open new collections to subscribers first.

Any store, as a spin wheel

  • Headline: "Spin for a welcome gift"
  • Line: "Every spin wins: free shipping, 10% off or a free sample"
  • Button: "Spin the wheel"
  • After the spin: "You won free shipping. Enter your email to see your code."

Name the real prizes in the line, so shoppers know what they're playing for. To draft a pop-up and check it against points like these, try the free sign-up pop-up checklist.

What should an email sign-up disclaimer say?

Keep the consent line to one or two sentences under the field: what people will receive, that they can unsubscribe at any time and where your privacy policy is. A version you can paste:

By signing up, you agree to receive marketing emails from [Store name]. Unsubscribe anytime. [Privacy policy]

Wix's form help notes that rules for marketing messages differ by location, so check what applies where you sell.

Lay it out for thumbs

  • Keep the field text at 16 pixels or larger. Safari on iPhone zooms in on any field with smaller text the moment it's tapped, which throws the layout off.
  • Put the button right under the field, so it stays in view above the keyboard.
  • Fit the headline on two lines on a phone. If it wraps to three, cut words until it doesn't.
  • Catch typos politely. Check the address when the button is tapped, explain any problem beside the field, and keep what they typed.

Test one change at a time

  1. Change one thing: the headline, the offer, the trigger or the number of fields.
  2. Run each version for at least a full week, so weekday and weekend visitors both count.
  3. Compare sign-ups per visitor who saw the pop-up, not raw sign-ups, which rise and fall with traffic.
  4. Log the date, the change and the result. Months later, it's the only reliable record of what you tried.

For worked examples and the numbers behind them, read this research on pop-up makeovers.

Frequently asked questions

Should an email pop-up offer a discount?

Not necessarily. A discount gives people a clear reason to sign up, but it costs you on every order that uses it, including orders that would have happened anyway. Free shipping, a free sample, early access to new products or useful tips can also give people a reason to join. Whatever you offer, state it plainly in the headline.

Should I use double opt-in for email sign-ups?

Use it if a clean list and a clear record of consent matter more to you than every last sign-up, because some people never confirm. Double opt-in asks each new subscriber to confirm by tapping a link in an email before they join your list, which keeps typos and fake addresses out and leaves a clear record that the person agreed. On Wix, new Wix Forms with a Subscribe field have an Enable double opt-in toggle, and sign-ups show as Subscription Pending until they confirm. If you turn it on, tell people in the pop-up to check their inbox.

What's the difference between a pop-up and an embedded sign-up form?

A pop-up appears over the page at a moment you choose, such as after a delay or when a visitor seems ready to leave. An embedded form sits inside the page, often in the footer, and waits for people to find it. A pop-up is harder to miss, while an embedded form never interrupts anyone. Most stores can use both, and growing your email list on Wix covers every other place to ask.

Where do pop-up sign-ups go?

On Wix, into your site's contacts, whether they come from a Wix Subscribe form or from Spin Wheel. A Wix Subscribe form adds each person to your contacts with a Subscriber label, and Spin Wheel saves every sign-up there with the consent the shopper gave. Spin Wheel also lists every sign-up on its Submissions page, on Shopify and Wix. It doesn't send marketing emails itself, so you follow up with the email tool you already use.

Try it on your store

Spin Wheel's email sign-up pop-up for Shopify and Wix stores collects an email, plus a phone number with its own tick box for texts if you want one.

Spin Wheel Free forever on Shopify and Wix

Sources

Written by the myuser.ai team

We build marketing apps for online stores: myuser.ai writes and sends emails and texts from a store's own products, and we make Spin Wheel and Session Recordings, free apps for online stores. Product details in our guides are checked against the apps themselves.

Give your next visitor a reason to sign up

Add Spin Wheel, pick a design AI made from your store, and start collecting sign-ups with prizes that work at checkout.

Add to Shopify Add to Wix Free forever · Shopify and Wix · No code